To begin this series, I’ll start with discussing a post by someone blogging as “Girl with a Dragonfly Tattoo”. It’s part of some interminable series on Proverbs 31, the love of Christian women everywhere. I love the Proverbs 31 wife too, she’s a comfort and joy to read about along with all the other idealized portraits in the Bible. It’s nice to see an ideal written up. But it’s an ideal. She’s not a real human woman like Miriam or Leah or even mother of God Mary.
Anyway, the basic overview is typical for Red Pill Women. You’re supposed to get up super early, that part about servants is meaningless. There’s of course no *real* obstacles to early rising, you just have to want to be holy enough! She even references her mother as an early riser, because five year old children are great recordkeepers.
But more to my core points, she references *rich people who use stimulants and have paid staff* as her model for what housewives nursing and getting pregnant frequently should do to be more productive. This is pretty typical of Red Pill Women. They do the same thing the men they identify with do of hyperfocusing on a narrow group of privileged people as if they are the norm. Only here SAHMs are supposed to behave like male executives on amphetamines who have wives, nannies and secretaries and personal assistants. But the SAHM is NOT supposed to have those things, oh no!
Because a maid is “unimaginable luxury”. Yes, in this TLDR; post about the Proverbs 31 wife, the OP conveniently declares the servant verses to be metaphorical, but the rising early verses to be worth charts and figures and paragraphs of hectoring. But fifty bucks every other week so you can stay on top of the household cleaning more easily and have a little free time to try that getting up early? UNIMAGINABLE LUXURY. And clearly a teenage homeschooled girl coming over every other morning so you can be a little more rested on known busy days, well, that isn’t even in her blog post. Even though teenaged nursemaids are a thing, historically.
Red Pill Women don’t appear to be aware there are any other women in the Bible except this one imaginary one and then they ignore the fact that she is a wealthy man’s wife and almost certainly the daughter of a wealthy man as well with her own dowered property/jewels/livestock. The point of this fictional wife was to emphasize the rarity, the uncommonness. Such a woman is supposed to be rarer than rubies, a beautiful ideal. She isn’t supposed to have all her qualities peeled away and converted into exciting new ways to overwork married mothers of young children and deny them the historical levels of other-women support they used to have in the patriarchal days of yore.
I even agree with “Girl With A Dragonfly Tattoo” about the importance of sleep. But you know what? The average SAHM simply isn’t given the resources to get a full night’s sleep and “go to bed earlier” doesn’t work if you’re combining it with “do whatever your husband wants”. A lot of men want to stay up late to relax. You can read old books and see that this is just part of the beautiful sex differences men and women have. Women used to be allowed to go on to bed on their own so that they could get some extra sleep.
But the Red Pill says that this would not be submissive, respectful, etc. Essentially all the “tips” she suggests on how to get more sleep assume some or all of a husband who wants to go to bed early every night, kids who sleep well whether nursed or formula fed, kids widely spaced (4+ years apart), fewer than three kids, no special needs kids, a husband who doesn’t want to use electronics or television after hours, and the ability to have private areas to focus on self-care such as the basics of the female toilet and hygiene. I can keep going, but my point is that under the current anti-social setup most housewives have, her tips and tricks *WILL NOT WORK* for months to years on end. One bad sleeper can trigger responses in the female body that include phantom screaming or lowered ability to sleep deeply.
So she wants SAHMs to be as productive as executives functioning on very little sleep, but without their resources. And yet if a woman does prioritize getting that sleep, she’s still somehow a badwife, since she chooses for her example of getting more sleep a woman who didn’t get up early to serve her husband and slept in instead. Broad social norms are antimatter for Red Pill Women. But they are the only way women can be protected enough to do their work and serve and love their husbands and families in a consistent way.